Madhya Pradesh, India – Shailbala Martin, a prominent IAS officer, has ignited a fresh wave of controversy with her recent social media post questioning the use of loudspeakers in temples, drawing sharp reactions from various Hindu organizations. In a discussion on the impact of noise pollution in the state, Martin responded to a user who criticized loudspeakers at religious gatherings by asking, “What about the loudspeakers on the temples?” She highlighted that these devices often blare until midnight, potentially disturbing nearby residents.
Her comments have since led to a backlash from right-wing groups who feel her statements undermine Hindu sentiments. Hindutva organization leaders, such as Pandit Chandrasekhar Tiwari, president of Sanskriti Bhachu Mancha, have expressed outrage over Martin's remarks. Tiwari stated, “Shailbala Martin's statement will hurt the sentiments of Hindus,” emphasizing that the chanting of mantras and aartis in temples is not comparable to the call of Azan from mosques. He warned of impending protests against the officer, asserting that her comments discredit the religious practices of Hindus.
The matter has also drawn reactions from political circles. Congress spokesperson Abbas Hafeez defended Martin, stating, “She did not say anything wrong. The BJP government has taken action against loudspeakers based on religion. It is time to challenge the actions of the Madhya Pradesh administration.” As the debate unfolds, it raises critical questions about the intersection of religion, noise pollution, and the rights of communities to practice their faith without disturbance. With both sides firmly entrenched in their views, the discussion is poised to ignite further protests and dialogue within the state and beyond. The situation remains fluid, and it remains to be seen how both the government and the public will navigate the ongoing discourse surrounding this sensitive issue.